Is it blasphemous for me to suggest skipping pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving in favor of this pudding? Maybe. But honestly, I almost never have room for heavy pie after stuffing my face with turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and gravy. This pumpkin pudding has all the taste of pumpkin pie but the cool, creamy, light texture is so good after a big meal. And it’s a delicious sweet treat any time- not just on Thanksgiving! You only need 15 minutes to whip up a batch of this pumpkin pudding, and then just refrigerate it (for at least two hours) until you’re ready to eat. You can even assemble individual portions ahead of time in dessert glasses or stemless wine glasses, layered with crumbled gingersnaps, all ready to go for your guests. And this homemade pumpkin pudding recipe is made entirely from scratch with only a few ingredients – no pudding mixes or sweetened condensed milk here!
Ingredients for Pumpkin Pudding
Whole milk – I don’t recommend low fat, since this is dessert, but you can use it if you really want to. Half and half would also work for a richer version.Pumpkin puree – the canned stuff. NOT pumpkin pie mix- just pureed pumpkin.Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix – here’s how to make your own pumpkin pie spice with ingredients already in your pantry.Sugar – plain old white sugar is great, but brown sugar will also work (the color of the pudding will be darker if you use brown sugar).Cornstarch – this is crucial for thickening it.Salt – just a pinch, to help balance the sweetness.Egg yolks – you can use 2 whole eggs in place of 4 egg yolks if you really want, but the texture won’t be the same and the color won’t be as rich. Just throw the leftover egg whites in a frittata or quiche so they don’t go to waste!Vanilla Extract – you can omit this if you like, or use maple extract instead.Salted butter – this is stirred in at the end for a delicious rich flavor and texture. Use unsalted if you like, with a pinch more salt in the pudding itself.
How to make Pumpkin Pudding from Scratch
How to store and cool the pudding
Once the pudding has cooled a little bit, pour it into a bowl or container and press a piece of plastic wrap onto the surface and stick in the refrigerator for 2 hours, or until you are ready to serve. Alternatively, you can layer the pudding in individual dessert glasses (stemless wine glasses work great for this) with crumbled gingersnap cookies. I smash my gingersnaps in a large zip top bag with a rolling pin. Whether you make fancy layered individual portions or just throw the whole batch in a bowl, it’s delicious topped with crumbled gingersnaps and whipped cream.
1. Is pudding the same thing as custard?
Kind of. Usually, custard is thickened entirely from egg yolks, whereas pudding has egg yolks as well as a starch (in this case, cornstarch). But some custard recipes do use both egg and starch or even other thickeners like gelatin. Both can be baked or made on the stovetop. So I guess you can call this pumpkin custard if you like!
2. How long is it good for in the fridge?
This homemade pumpkin pudding will last 5-7 days in the fridge. I suggest pressing a piece of plastic wrap on the surface to prevent a skin from forming and keeping it in an airtight container.
3. Can you freeze pumpkin pudding?
Yes, you can. And it might be a good idea to add it to popsicle molds for a frozen treat! But keep in mind the texture may change a bit if it’s frozen. Once it’s thawed out, stir it up a bit if there is any separation. Freeze in an airtight container for up to 2 months.
4. Does this pudding have raw eggs?
Nope! This pudding is heated on the stovetop until the eggs are cooked all the way through.
5. Can this be made dairy free?
I haven’t personally tried it, but I think you can likely use a plant-based milk and skip the butter in the end for a dairy free version. Or, try this vegan pumpkin pudding recipe.
Other make-ahead dessert recipes
Butterscotch Pudding from ScratchMaple Cinnamon PuddingDutch Butter CakeMeyer Lemon BarsPineapple Cheesecake WhipTwo-Ingredient Rice Pudding
Did you know commenting and rating recipes is one of the best ways you can support your favorite food bloggers? If you made this recipe or have a question, please click the stars below to comment and Rate this Recipe and/or share photos on social media using the hashtag #bowlofdelicious or tagging @bowlofdelicious!
